Home › Articles

US-Domiciled ETFs or Irish UCITS? VOO vs CSPX and QQQM vs CNDX on Tax and US Estate Tax

2026-10-17 · Research note · Not investment advice; figures are as of the sources and dates cited in the text · 中文
Contents6 sections
  1. The conclusion first
  2. Model assumptions
  3. Cost only: why the two indices give opposite answers
  4. Adding estate tax: both indices flip
  5. How to use this conclusion
  6. Frequently asked questions

To track the S&P 500 you can buy the US-domiciled VOO or the Ireland-domiciled CSPX; to track the Nasdaq 100 there are QQQM and CNDX. For non-resident aliens (NRAs), that is, investors who are not US persons, such as investors in Taiwan, the difference between the two choices is not the index but three things: how much dividend tax is withheld, how high the expense ratio is, and whether US estate tax is due on death. This article works through all three with a 30-year compounding model.

This is a model under simplified assumptions, not tax or investment advice. For actual tax law, tax treaties and your own situation, rely on an accountant or tax lawyer. The model's source files can be downloaded from this site's ETF tax page (Chinese) (including 24 Excel files with adjustable parameters).

The conclusion first

Scenario S&P 500 Nasdaq 100
Holding cost only (ignoring death) CSPX (UCITS) is better QQQM (US-domiciled) is better
Including US estate tax risk CSPX (UCITS) is better CNDX (UCITS) is better

In other words: on cost alone, the two indices give opposite answers; once estate tax is considered, UCITS wins for both indices, and by a margin large enough that the cost difference becomes almost negligible.

Model assumptions

Parameter Value
Gross return (annual) 10%
S&P 500 dividend yield 1.3%
Nasdaq 100 dividend yield 0.5%
Dividend withholding tax, US-domiciled ETF 30% (non-US resident, no treaty reduction)
Fund-level withholding tax, Irish UCITS ETF 15% (Ireland-US tax treaty)
Purchase commission US-listed 0.1%, UK-listed 0.25% (assumed sub-brokerage rates)
US estate tax exemption for non-resident aliens USD 60,000; the excess is taxed progressively (top rate about 40%)
Period 30 years

Cost only: why the two indices give opposite answers

US-domiciled ETFs have lower expense ratios, but their dividends are withheld at 30%; UCITS ETFs charge slightly more, but their dividends are withheld at only 15%. So the higher the dividend yield, the larger the UCITS withholding advantage:

  • The S&P 500 has a higher yield (about 1.3%), so the withholding gap outweighs the fee gap and UCITS wins. With USD 80,000 of principal, after 30 years: VOO is about 1,243,043 USD and CSPX about 1,295,263 USD; CSPX ends 52,220 USD ahead.
  • The Nasdaq 100 yields very little (about 0.5%), so the withholding gap is small, the fee advantage dominates, and the US-domiciled fund wins. With USD 80,000 of principal, after 30 years: QQQM is about 1,284,733 USD and CNDX about 1,256,872 USD; QQQM ends 27,860 USD ahead.

With principal of USD 40,000, 160,000 or 1,000,000 instead, the winner is the same in each case; the amounts simply scale proportionally.

Adding estate tax: both indices flip

For non-resident aliens, a US-domiciled ETF is US-situs property. When the holder dies, the portion above USD 60,000 is subject to US estate tax, and the larger the estate, the higher the effective rate. Ireland-domiciled UCITS ETFs do not have this problem.

Taking USD 80,000 of principal as an example:

Year of death VOO estate US estate tax Effective rate VOO after tax CSPX received CSPX advantage
Year 10 199,495 41,638 20.9% 157,857 202,048 44,191
Year 20 497,977 142,112 28.5% 355,865 511,571 155,707
Year 30 1,243,043 430,017 34.6% 813,026 1,295,263 482,237

The Nasdaq 100 is the same: with USD 80,000 of principal and death in Year 10, QQQM's effective estate tax rate already reaches 21%, and CNDX delivers 40,675 USD more than QQQM after tax. By comparison, the pure holding-cost gap over the same period is only a little over a thousand dollars. The impact of estate tax is more than an order of magnitude larger than the cost gap.

How to use this conclusion

  1. Non-resident aliens who hold long term and whose position will exceed USD 60,000: estate tax risk is the main consideration, and both indices lean toward UCITS (CSPX, CNDX). This is why this site's entry adjudication and tactical instruments use CSPX/CNDX.
  2. Small positions, or ones you are sure to sell soon: estate tax risk is lower and you can look at cost alone. For the S&P 500 CSPX is still better; for the Nasdaq 100 QQQM is better.
  3. Do not overlook trading differences: UCITS ETFs are listed on the London Stock Exchange, with trading hours different from US markets, a higher assumed commission, and some brokers do not support them.

For live prices and returns of these ETFs, see the individual pages for CSPX (Chinese), VOO (Chinese), CNDX (Chinese) and QQQ (Chinese), or overlay them directly in the watchlist comparison (Chinese). For methodology, see "A Beginner's Guide to Quantitative US Stock Investing".

Frequently asked questions

Which is better, VOO or CSPX?

According to this model, CSPX is better for non-resident aliens: on cost alone, the S&P 500's higher yield means the UCITS advantage of only 15% dividend withholding outweighs the fee gap; add the fact that CSPX carries no US estate tax risk, and the gap grows larger.

Which is better, QQQM or CNDX?

On holding cost alone, QQQM is better, because the Nasdaq 100's yield is very low, the withholding gap is small and the fee advantage dominates. But if the position may exceed USD 60,000 and is held long term, CNDX clearly wins once US estate tax risk is included.

Do Taiwanese investors holding US ETFs owe US estate tax?

For non-resident aliens, US-domiciled ETFs are US-situs property. When the holder dies, the portion above the USD 60,000 exemption may be subject to US estate tax, at progressive rates with a top rate of about 40%. Ireland-domiciled UCITS ETFs do not have this problem. Consult a tax professional for how this applies to you.

Why is dividend withholding lower for UCITS ETFs?

Ireland has a tax treaty with the US, so an Irish fund receiving US stock dividends is withheld at only 15%; a non-resident alien holding a US-domiciled ETF directly has dividends withheld at 30%. Accumulating UCITS ETFs automatically reinvest after-tax dividends, which is reflected in the net asset value.

What are the limitations of this model?

Returns, yields and fees are fixed assumptions, while in reality they change every year; estate tax covers only the US layer and ignores each country's local tax system; exchange rates, bid-ask spreads and broker differences are not included either. The direction of the conclusion is more reliable than the exact amounts.

More articles

← All articles Open today's market dashboard →

Contents