2026 YTD Market Data for Three S&P 500 ETFs (VOO / 00646 / CSPX)
Contents8 sections
- One. Year-end closes, latest closes and own-calculated YTD: do they match Google?
- Two. 00646 market price, NAV and premium/discount
- Three. NAV and premium/discount of VOO and CSPX
- Four. Distribution policy and the gap between price return and total return
- Five. Trading time zones and the date of Google's latest point
- Six. Expense ratios, tracking error, withholding tax and 00646's holdings structure
- Further reading
- Frequently asked questions
Data collected: 2026-10-20 (Taipei time). Prices come mainly from Yahoo Finance chart API daily data (query1.finance.yahoo.com/v8/finance/chart/<ticker>) and TWSE official daily trading data; NAVs come mainly from the issuers' websites. Any percentage not labelled "source value" was calculated from the actual closing prices below (formula: latest price ÷ base price − 1).
About this page: This is the full, verbatim text of the research note
sp500_group.mdin the research_notes folder on Taiwan, US and UK ETF return differences; only the table of contents at the top of the original has been removed, and no figure, table, cited link or "Gaps" (not found) passage has been changed. Data were collected on 2026-10-20 (Taipei time). Each section in the original has four parts: Takeaway (the conclusion), Cited Findings (sourced data), Inferences (reasoning), and Gaps (data not found or not obtained); percentages not labelled "source value" were all calculated by the author from the closing prices cited in the text (latest price ÷ base price − 1). The HiStock link in the original is a Chinese-character URL; this English version writes the same address in percent-encoded form. This note is one of the working papers behind "Currency, Base Dates and the Wrong Ticker Create the Illusion That Taiwan-Listed ETFs Lead". It is a research record, not investment advice.
One. Year-end closes, latest closes and own-calculated YTD: do they match Google?
Takeaway
All three of Google's figures can be reproduced exactly from actual closing prices, but the base dates are inconsistent: VOO uses the 2025-12-31 close, while 00646 and CSPX use the 2026-01-02 close (the first trading day of 2026). With 2025-12-31 as a common base, YTD price returns are VOO +12.35%, CSPX +12.87% (10/19 close) and 00646 +16.35% (in NT dollars). 00646 is higher mainly because the NT dollar fell about 3.7%–4.3%, which has nothing to do with the underlying's performance.
Cited Findings
Actual closing prices (end of 2025 and the latest trading days)
| Ticker | Currency | 2025-12-31 close | 2026-01-02 close | 2026-10-16 close | 2026-10-19 close | 2026-10-20 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| VOO (NYSE Arca) | USD | 627.13 | 628.30 | 701.61 | 704.60 | US market not yet open |
| 00646 (TWSE) | TWD | 67.90 | 67.85 | 79.35 | 79.00 | Close 79.00 (change 0.00) |
| CSPX (LSE) | USD | 738.53 | 733.52 | 832.99 | 833.61 (see note below) | Intraday (Google shows 831.68) |
| SPY (for reference) | USD | 681.92 | 683.17 | 763.25 | 766.48 | — |
- VOO closed at 627.13 on 2025-12-31, 701.61 on 10/16 and 704.60 on 10/19; exchange NYSE Arca (PCX), currency USD — Yahoo Finance chart API VOO
- VOO 10/19 close $704.60 (+2.99, +0.43%), previous close $701.61 — stockanalysis.com VOO
- 00646 official daily trading: close 67.90 on 114/12/31; close 67.85 on 115/01/02; close 79.35 on 115/10/16; close 79.00 on 115/10/19 (−0.35); close 79.00 on 115/10/20 (0.00) — TWSE daily trading information 2025-12, 2026-01, 2026-10
- Yahoo's 00646 data show currency TWD and exchange Taiwan, and match the TWSE closes — Yahoo Finance chart API 00646.TW
- CSPX.L: currency USD, exchange LSE; close 738.53 on 2025-12-31, 733.52 on 2026-01-02, 832.99 on 10/16; the daily-bar field for 10/19 is empty, but
regularMarketPriceis 833.61 (timestamp 2026-10-20 07:31 BST, i.e. around the 10/20 open) — Yahoo Finance chart API CSPX.L - SPY closed at 681.92 on 2025-12-31 and 766.48 on 10/19 — Yahoo Finance chart API SPY
Own-calculated YTD versus Google's figures
| Ticker | Google shows | Own calculation, 12/31 base | Base backed out from Google's figures | Consistent? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| VOO | 704.60, +77.47, +12.35% | 704.60 ÷ 627.13 − 1 = +12.353%, +77.47 | 704.60 − 77.47 = 627.13 = 2025-12-31 close | Consistent |
| 00646 | 79.00, +11.15, +16.43% | 79.00 ÷ 67.90 − 1 = +16.348%, +11.10 | 79.00 − 11.15 = 67.85 = 2026-01-02 close (+16.433% from 67.85) | Reproducible, but the base is 1/2 |
| CSPX | 831.68, +98.16, +13.38% | 831.68 ÷ 738.53 − 1 = +12.613%; from the 10/19 close of 833.61, +12.874% | 831.68 − 98.16 = 733.52 = 2026-01-02 close (+13.382% from 733.52) | Reproducible, but the base is 1/2 |
| SPY (reference) | — | 766.48 ÷ 681.92 − 1 = +12.40% | — | — |
(The calculations above are based on the same Yahoo / TWSE closes as the table above)
Inferences
- Google's YTD base dates are inconsistent: VOO uses the 2025-12-31 close, while 00646 and CSPX both use the 2026-01-02 close. CSPX fell 0.68% between 12/31 and 1/2 (738.53 → 733.52); with 1/2 as the base, CSPX's YTD looks about 0.77 percentage points higher, which is the main reason "UK > US". 00646 differs by only NT$0.05 between those two days, an effect of about 0.08 percentage points.
- With 12/31 as a common base for all three: VOO's price return is +12.35% (10/19), and CSPX's is +12.87% (10/19 LSE close) and +12.79% (10/16), almost the same. Given that VOO pays distributions and CSPX accumulates, the gap between the US and UK funds disappears (see section four).
- 00646's +16.35% is in NT dollars. According to Yahoo's USD/TWD quotes, the rate was 31.2436 on 12/31, 32.387 on 10/19 (+3.66%) and 32.593 on 10/20 (+4.32%) (Yahoo Finance TWD=X). A rough estimate: VOO's US-dollar total return of 12.85%–13.33% multiplied by an exchange-rate rise of 3.66%–4.32% gives about +17.0% to +18.2% (1.1285×1.0366−1 and 1.1333×1.0432−1). 00646's actual +16.35% is below that; the gap can be broadly explained by the 0.36% expense ratio, the 30% US dividend withholding tax, changes in premium/discount, and differences in the timing of NAV calculation and of the exchange rate used, but this is an inference without an item-by-item breakdown.
Gaps
- No official explanation was found for why Google uses the 1/2 close as the base for 00646 / CSPX (presumably a result of how non-US-listed products are handled; unconfirmed).
- For CSPX's official LSE close on 10/19, Yahoo's daily bar is empty; 833.61 was obtained by cross-checking
regularMarketPriceagainst the "previous close 833.61" Google shows, and no official LSE closing data were obtained. - No official USD/TWD closing rates from the Bank of Taiwan or the central bank for 12/31 and 10/19 were obtained; only Yahoo quotes.
Two. 00646 market price, NAV and premium/discount
Takeaway
00646 is priced in NT dollars. On 10/19 the official NAV was 78.61 and the market price 79.00, a premium of about 0.50%; after the close on 10/20 the estimated NAV was 78.95, a premium of 0.06% (TWSE), or NAV 78.84 and a premium of 0.20% (wantgoo). Over the last 20 trading days the premium/discount ranged from −0.96% to +1.69%; 10/14 (+1.51%) and 10/16 (+1.69%) were high, but by 10/19 and 10/20 it had fallen back below 0.5%, so it does not noticeably inflate the YTD.
Cited Findings
- Yuanta Funds PCF: data date 2026/10/19, NAV per unit NTD 78.61, net fund assets NTD 50,504,515,994, units outstanding 642,485,000 — Yuanta Funds 00646 PCF
- TWSE basic market information, real-time ETF data (2026-10-20 15:09:45): last price 79.0, fund company's estimated NAV 78.95, estimated premium/discount +0.06%, previous business day's NAV per unit 78.6100, units outstanding 642,485,000 — TWSE MIS all_etf
- wantgoo premium/discount table (excerpt): 10/20 price 79 / NAV 78.84 / +0.20%; 10/19 79 / 78.61 / +0.50%; 10/16 79.35 / 78.03 / +1.69%; 10/15 78.15 / 78.91 / −0.96%; 10/14 79.25 / 78.07 / +1.51%; 10/13 78.65 / 78.93 / −0.35%; 10/12 78.8 / 78.36 / +0.56%; 9/18 to 10/08 all between −0.92% and +0.96% — wantgoo 00646 premium/discount
- MoneyDJ: market price 79.00 (10/19), NAV 78.61 (labelled 10/16), premium/discount 0.50% (monthly average 0.19%) — MoneyDJ 00646 basic data; the NAV date label is inconsistent with Yuanta's website (78.61 is the 10/19 figure) and wantgoo (the 10/16 NAV is 78.03); Yuanta's website should be taken as correct
- Earlier premium/discount: 2026/08/07 NAV 78.72, price 78.25, discount −0.60%; 8/04 discount −1.51%; 2026/07/24 premium 0.21% — the source is MoneyDJ and wantgoo as quoted in search-result summaries, not checked page by page
- Yuanta announced a NAV per unit of 74.99 on 2026/07/01 and fund assets of about 42.18 billion — from a search-result summary citing Yuanta Funds, not checked page by page
Inferences
- 00646's recent premium/discount has mostly been within ±1%, a normal range. The premiums above 1.5% on 10/14 and 10/16 may be a time-zone effect, with the Taiwan market following US futures intraday while NAV is calculated from the previous night's US close, but this is an inference.
- Google calculates the YTD from 79.00, and the premium that day (10/19) was only 0.50%, so an "abnormal premium inflating the number" is not the main reason 00646's YTD is high.
Gaps
- 00646's official NAV and premium/discount on 2025-12-31 (or 2026-01-02) were not found, so its NAV-based YTD cannot be calculated and the effect of the premium/discount difference between the base date and now on the YTD cannot be quantified.
- The TWSE MIS estimated NAV of 78.95 differs from wantgoo's 10/20 NAV of 78.84; the reason was not checked (possibly the difference between an estimated and a final value).
Three. NAV and premium/discount of VOO and CSPX
Takeaway
CSPX's official NAV on 10/19 was USD 829.8952, with a YTD NAV total return of +12.71% (iShares, as of 10/16). VOO's NAV could not be found on either Vanguard's website or stockanalysis.
Cited Findings
- CSPX (USD Acc) NAV USD 829.8952 (2026-10-19), daily change +3.37 (+0.41%); YTD NAV total return 12.71% (as of 2026-10-16); 52-week range 681.22 to 843.55 — iShares CSPX product page
- CSPX net assets USD 153,100,996,625, units outstanding 187,038,870 (2026-08-03) — from a search-result summary citing BlackRock UK CSPX
- VOO: Vanguard's product page loads dynamically with JS, so the NAV could not be fetched; the stockanalysis page has no NAV either — Vanguard VOO, stockanalysis VOO
Inferences
- CSPX's 10/19 market price of 833.61 is +0.45% against its NAV of 829.8952, but the LSE close (16:30 London, about 11:30 New York) comes before the NAV pricing time (the US close), so this gap mainly reflects the time difference and cannot be treated as a true premium.
- CSPX's market-price YTD (12/31 → 10/16) of +12.79% is close to its official YTD NAV total return of +12.71% (also as of 10/16), showing that CSPX's market price did not deviate noticeably from NAV.
Gaps
- VOO's NAV and premium/discount were not found (the Vanguard page requires JS and the API endpoint returned nothing). VOO is a US ETF with about 1.06 trillion US dollars in assets, and its premium/discount is usually tiny, but no actual figure was obtained this time.
- No official premium/discount data for CSPX on the LSE were found.
Four. Distribution policy and the gap between price return and total return
Takeaway
VOO has gone ex-dividend 3 times in 2026, for a total of $5.6572, making its price return about 0.97 percentage points lower than its total return (12.35% versus 13.33%). CSPX accumulates and pays no distributions, so its price is approximately its total return. 00646 is nominally an annual distributor but has never paid a distribution since launch.
Cited Findings
- VOO's 2026 ex-dividend amounts: 3/27 $1.8724, 6/26 $1.9622, 9/28 $1.8226; yield 1.05% — stockanalysis VOO; Yahoo lists the same amounts (1.872 / 1.962 / 1.823) — Yahoo Finance chart API VOO
- Yahoo's adjusted closes for VOO: 621.7428 on 2025-12-31 and 704.60 on 10/19 → adjusted (dividends-included) YTD +13.327%; +12.846% as of 10/16 (same calculation basis)
- SPY for reference: price YTD +12.40%, adjusted YTD +13.28% (12/31 adjusted price 676.635) — Yahoo Finance chart API SPY
- CSPX is an accumulating fund (dividends reinvested, not paid out), Irish-domiciled, full physical replication — justETF CSPX; iShares labels it "USD (Accumulating)" — iShares CSPX
- 00646's distribution frequency is labelled "annual", yield N/A — MoneyDJ 00646; HiStock's ex-rights and ex-dividend page has no distribution records — HiStock 00646 ex-rights and ex-dividend; Pocket School says the prospectus specifies annual distributions, but the fund has accumulated and paid nothing since launch — Pocket School
- Yahoo's 00646 data show no dividend events during 2026 — Yahoo Finance chart API 00646.TW
Inferences
- On the same basis (dividends included, 12/31 base): VOO's total return is +12.85% (10/16) / +13.33% (10/19), and CSPX's is +12.79% (10/16 market price) and NAV +12.71% (10/16); the two differ by only 0.06 to 0.14 percentage points, broadly consistent with CSPX's higher expense ratio (0.07% versus 0.03%) and the dividend withholding tax (15%). The VOO figure Google uses is a price return that excludes distributions, which is why VOO looks lower.
Gaps
- Vanguard's official NAV / market-price YTD total return for VOO was not found.
Five. Trading time zones and the date of Google's "latest" point
Takeaway
The three "latest prices" the user saw fall on different dates and times: VOO is the 10/19 New York close, 00646 is the 10/20 Taipei close and CSPX is 10/20 London intraday. Their "previous closes" also fall on different dates.
Cited Findings
- VOO:
regularMarketTimeis 2026-10-19 16:00 (New York, EDT, UTC−4), price 704.60; the previous close of 701.61 is the 10/16 close — Yahoo Finance chart API VOO, stockanalysis VOO - 00646:
regularMarketTimeis 2026-10-20 13:30 (Taipei, UTC+8); TWSE closes were 79.00 on 10/19 and 79.00 on 10/20, so Google's "previous close 79.00" is the 10/19 close and the day's change is 0.00 — TWSE 2026-10 daily trading - CSPX: time zone BST (UTC+1),
regularMarketTime2026-10-20 07:31; 10/16 close 832.99 — Yahoo Finance chart API CSPX.L
Inferences
- At the Taipei close on 10/20, 00646 already reflected the US rise on 10/19 (VOO +0.43%). CSPX's 831.68 is a London intraday price on 10/20, 0.23% below the 10/19 close of 833.61, reflecting futures moves before the US open on 10/20. VOO's 704.60 is still at 10/19. The three "latest" points are not at the same time, but the time difference accounts for less than about ±0.5 percentage points and is not the main cause of the YTD gap.
- The daily "previous close" is also inconsistent: VOO's is 10/16, 00646's is 10/19 and CSPX's is 10/19.
Gaps
- The price timestamp of the Google Finance chart itself could not be obtained directly; it can only be cross-checked using Yahoo's timestamps and the figures Google shows.
Six. Expense ratios, tracking error, withholding tax and 00646's holdings structure
Takeaway
Expense ratios: VOO 0.03%, CSPX 0.07%, 00646 total expense ratio 0.36% (management fee 0.30%). 00646 directly holds about 503 US stocks plus a small amount of ES futures, and holds no ETFs such as SPY. On dividend withholding tax, 00646 is generally thought to be subject to 30%, CSPX to 15% (under the Ireland–US tax treaty), and VOO is not withheld at the fund level, but non-US investors are withheld on its distributions.
Cited Findings
- VOO expense ratio 0.03%, launched 2010-09-07, assets about $1.06T — stockanalysis VOO
- CSPX TER 0.07%, Irish-domiciled, full physical replication, fund size EUR 137,707m — justETF CSPX; justETF also lists a YTD of +19.06% without stating the currency or date; it differs widely from the USD-priced +12.7%, may be calculated in EUR, and is not used
- CSPX's 1-year return to 2026-07 was 19.28%, versus 19.14% for its benchmark index — from a search-result summary citing the iShares CSPX fact sheet, not checked page by page
- 00646 management fee 0.3%, total expense ratio 0.36% (including 0.06% of non-management expenses), launched 2015/12/02, listed 2015/12/14 — MoneyDJ 00646
- 00646 holdings structure (2026/10/19): stocks NTD 49,733,377,595 (about 98.5% of net assets); futures 1.52% (E-mini S&P 500 futures ES 2026/12, 61 contracts); cash 1.53%; 503 holdings in total, 98.47% in the US; ETF amount NTD 0, i.e. no holdings of ETFs such as SPY; top five NVDA 7.81%, AAPL 7.44%, MSFT 5.89%, AMZN 3.83%, GOOGL 3.00% — Yuanta Funds 00646 PCF
- 00646 withholding tax: a blog post says the US withholds 30% on dividends received by the fund, which at an S&P 500 yield of about 1.8% is a hidden drag of about 0.54% a year; long-run tracking error is about −0.5% to −1.1% — uptogo (unofficial source); Pocket School says there is "no US dividend withholding tax issue" — Pocket School, which contradicts the former; it should be read as meaning investors do not face the tax directly, while the fund itself is still withheld
- An article says the withholding rate on US dividends for Irish-domiciled accumulating ETFs is 15% — from a search-result summary citing uptogo (unofficial source)
Inferences
- From lowest to highest annual cost, the order is roughly VOO < CSPX < 00646; 00646's combined fees and taxes are clearly the highest. 00646's higher YTD is the result of the NT-dollar exchange rate and Google's base date, and does not mean it tracks better.
Gaps
- Official tracking-error / tracking-difference figures for the three funds were not found (the iShares, Vanguard and Yuanta pages do not provide them directly).
- There is no official primary source (Yuanta prospectus or IRS) for 00646 being subject to 30% US withholding tax, only blog claims.
- No IRS or issuer primary documents were obtained this time for the 30% withholding rate on VOO for non-US investors or the 15% rate for CSPX.
Further reading
- Main article: "Currency, Base Dates and the Wrong Ticker Create the Illusion That Taiwan-Listed ETFs Lead" — the three measurement problems of currency, base date and wrong ticker in one piece.
- Other working papers in the series: "USD/TWD Exchange Rates and the US-Dollar Returns of Taiwan-Listed Overseas ETFs (00646 / 00662)" and "NASDAQ-100 Three-ETF Market Data Check (QQQ / 00662 / CNDX)".
- This site's VOO ETF page, CSPX ETF page and SSO ETF page (Chinese): daily prices, period returns, RSI and distance from the 52-week high.
- On the interactive site, compare VOO and CSPX year to date (Chinese) (price return, dividends excluded, with a uniform 12/31 starting close).
- Dividend withholding tax, fees and estate tax for US-domiciled versus Irish-domiciled ETFs: "US-domiciled ETF or Irish UCITS?".
- Another study on VOO: "RSI oversold crossovers buy low but rarely at the bottom".
Frequently asked questions
Which has the highest year-to-date return: VOO, 00646 or CSPX?
Google's figures can all be reproduced from actual closing prices, but the base dates are inconsistent: VOO uses the 2025-12-31 close, while 00646 and CSPX use the 2026-01-02 close. With 2025-12-31 as a common base, YTD price returns are VOO +12.35%, CSPX +12.87% (10/19 close) and 00646 +16.35% (in NT dollars). 00646 is higher mainly because the NT dollar fell about 3.7%–4.3%, which has nothing to do with the underlying's performance.
Why is CSPX's YTD higher than VOO's?
First, the base date: CSPX fell 0.68% between 12/31 and 1/2 (738.53 → 733.52), so with 1/2 as the base its YTD looks about 0.77 percentage points higher. Second, distributions: the VOO figure Google uses is a price return that excludes distributions, while CSPX accumulates. On the same basis (dividends included, 12/31 base), VOO's total return is +12.85% (10/16) / +13.33% (10/19) and CSPX's is +12.79% (10/16 market price) and NAV +12.71% (10/16); the two differ by only 0.06 to 0.14 percentage points.
Does 00646 pay distributions?
00646's distribution frequency is labelled "annual", but it has never paid a distribution since launch: MoneyDJ shows a yield of N/A, HiStock's ex-rights and ex-dividend page has no distribution records, and Yahoo shows no dividend events during 2026. VOO, by contrast, has gone ex-dividend 3 times in 2026, for a total of $5.6572, making its price return about 0.97 percentage points lower than its total return (12.35% versus 13.33%).
How large is 00646's premium/discount, and does it inflate the YTD?
On 10/19 the official NAV was 78.61 and the market price 79.00, a premium of about 0.50%; over the last 20 trading days the premium/discount ranged from −0.96% to +1.69%, with 10/14 (+1.51%) and 10/16 (+1.69%) high, but by 10/19 and 10/20 it had fallen back below 0.5%. The note judges that it does not noticeably inflate the YTD; the official NAV and premium/discount on the base date were not found, so the effect cannot be quantified.
How much do VOO, CSPX and 00646 differ in expense ratio and dividend withholding tax?
Expense ratios: VOO 0.03%, CSPX 0.07%, 00646 total expense ratio 0.36% (management fee 0.30%). On dividend withholding tax, 00646 is generally thought to be subject to 30%, CSPX to 15% (under the Ireland–US tax treaty), and VOO is not withheld at the fund level, but non-US investors are withheld on its distributions. No IRS or issuer primary documents were obtained for these rates this time, and 00646's 30% rests only on blog claims.
Does 00646 buy US stocks directly or hold SPY?
According to Yuanta Funds' PCF (2026/10/19), 00646 directly holds 503 US stocks, with stocks making up about 98.5% of net assets, plus E-mini S&P 500 futures ES (1.52%, 61 contracts) and cash of 1.53%; its ETF amount is NTD 0, meaning it holds no ETFs such as SPY. The top five are NVDA 7.81%, AAPL 7.44%, MSFT 5.89%, AMZN 3.83% and GOOGL 3.00%.